Skip to content
Utah Community Learning

You can't 'try harder' to sleep

About 18 minutes

You can't "try harder" to sleep

Okay. New module — "The Evening Wind-Down." We just spent a whole section on the bedroom itself: cool, dark, boring, humidifiers, descaling, all of it. Now we're backing up a step to talk about the hour or two before you even get in that bed.

And I want to start with the thing that took me the longest to actually believe.

You cannot try harder to sleep. It's the one weird exception to basically every other thing in life. You can try harder to run faster, save more money, be more patient with your kids. Effort usually helps. With sleep, effort is the enemy. The second you're lying there thinking "okay, come on, go to sleep, you have to be up in six hours," you've made it worse. Your brain treats that pressure like a task, and tasks keep you awake.

This was a hard one for me personally, because I'm a contractor. My whole professional life is "identify the problem, apply force, fix it." Sleep does not respond to that. Sleep responds to you removing obstacles and then getting out of your own way.

So this module isn't about tricks to fall asleep faster. It's about making the hour before bed boring enough that sleep just sort of happens to you, instead of something you're chasing.

The wind-down isn't a bedtime ritual, it's a decompression

Here's the thing — I used to think "wind-down routine" meant something like a spa night. Candles, whatever. It's not that. It's just: what's the last thing your brain is doing before you ask it to shut off?

For a long time, mine was reading on my phone in bed. Which sounds relaxing. I told myself it was relaxing. I'd read until midnight "just to wind down," and then lie there for another twenty minutes feeling wired even though I was tired.

I finally fact-checked my own excuse, because that's sort of my whole method — test the thing you're sure is true. I tracked it for about a week. Turned out the "winding down" wasn't winding me down at all. Bright screen, six inches from my face, usually reading something with a little bit of a hook to it — a group chat, an article, whatever. My brain was doing light work right up until the second I wanted it to switch off. That's not a wind-down, that's a stall.

The fix was moving my phone to charge in the kitchen. Not silence it, not "night mode" it — physically remove it from the bedroom.

This was, honestly, the hardest change I made in this whole process. Harder than the wine. Harder than the bath. I missed it like a habit, not like a need, if that makes sense.

What to actually do

Pick one thing to try this week, not five.

  1. Set a real cutoff time for screens — something concrete, like "phone's done at 9:30," not "I'll wind down eventually." Vague doesn't work. Vague is how you end up at midnight again.
  2. Move the charger out of the bedroom. This is the actual mechanism. If the phone's in reach, it will end up in your hand at 11pm, I promise you, it doesn't matter how much willpower you think you have at 8pm.
  3. Replace it with something boring on purpose. Not a project. Not a podcast that makes you think. A dumb TV rerun, a paper book you're not that invested in, folding laundry. The goal is low-stimulation, not zero-stimulation.
  4. Dim the lights while you do it. We covered this a couple lessons back — this is where that actually pays off, pairing dim light with the low-key activity.

One opinion I'll say straight out: I think most people reach for a supplement before they've done this free stuff. Melatonin gummy, magnesium, whatever's trending. And look, maybe those help some people, I'm not saying don't. But if you're scrolling in bed until midnight and then taking a gummy and wondering why it's not working — the gummy was never going to beat the phone. Fix the free thing first.

A real caution here

If you're someone whose brain won't quiet down no matter what you remove — actual racing thoughts, not just "I checked my phone too long" — that's worth mentioning to a doctor, especially if it's a nightly thing and not an occasional one. That's outside my lane. I can help you build a better evening. I can't diagnose anxiety or insomnia, and I won't pretend to.

Before next time

Pick your cutoff time and pick where the phone charges tonight. Write both down somewhere you'll actually see them tomorrow — I use the same notebook I track everything else in. We'll build on this next lesson.